Version 2 · a toy equation of motion. It is not lattice QCD.
For science students: each flavor has a real state (r, p, PDG mass, Q, and a color that is not glued to the name). The step is F = dp/dt from nature — σ ≈ 0.18 GeV², α = 1/137, G_N. The clock that maps fm/c onto your screen is the picture. Jennifer Kirchner accomplished this with Grok.
Be painfully honest: what is science, what is a picture
What is right
- Spin 1/2. Charge +2/3 or −1/3. PDG 2024 masses.
- Strong is flavor-blind. Same string tension σ on every color charge.
- EM is Coulomb F = qE from α. |F| ratio up/down = 2.
- Gravity is equivalence: a is the same for every mass. G_N × a proton is invisible here.
- No forces means inertial coast. Light quarks under σ go relativistic; |v| < c.
What is still a picture
The origin is standing in for “the other end of a flux tube” and for a +e Coulomb source. That is a 6-body toy, not gluons and not a proton. Weak is not a Newtonian push — CKM is still the mixing matrix, it just does not move r. There is no fifth force. ħ already sits in the units.
The five axes are a cube frame (xyz + XY and YZ), not extra spacetime. Spacetime fabric is a rubber-sheet drawing in its own tile: a GR picture of gravity, not a fifth force, and not 4D spacetime. Cube faces bounce the dots so they stay on stage — a box, not a fifth force. The only invented number in the step is the clock: how many fm/c pass per wall-clock second so you can watch.
Version 2 vs version 1
Version 1 already had the right labels (spin, Q, PDG masses, CKM). It used them to warp a drawn path. Version 2 uses them as inputs to F = dp/dt. That is a jump in the kind of model, not a 10% polish. Open the version 1 diagram.
| Piece | Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Motion | Lissajous + shrink/nudge | Inertia: no F ⇒ r + vt |
| Strong | Multiply r by 0.45 | Same σ ≈ 0.18 GeV² on every color |
| EM | Add q · α · 2.5 · half | Coulomb α ħc Q / r²; |F| up/down = 2 |
| Mass | Painted on, almost unused | Inertia. Top sits; up goes relativistic |
| Gravity | Heavier ⇒ bigger path shrink | Equivalence. G_N × m_p is invisible |
| Color | Glued to flavor name | SU(3) label on the state |
| c | Not a rule | v = p/E, |v| < c |
| Weak | Fake path mix, painted as a force | Listed as a force. Does not invent F_W on r |
At 1 fm, version 2’s force ratio is from nature: |F_strong| / |F_EM,up| ≈ 950. Version 1 forced strong and EM to look comparable on screen. That is a thousand-fold honesty gain on hierarchy.
What did not get more accurate: six classical points and a fake origin. No gluons, no lattice QCD, no hadrons. The clock is invented. The laws that move the dots went from metaphor to freshman relativity + SM constants. The system those laws run on is still a classroom toy.
Accomplished by Jennifer Kirchner with Grok.